Skip to content

Does natural gas make sense as a truck fuel? Why not use it to make stuff that’s easier to handle?

by Tom Berg, Senior Editor

Natural gas! Almost everything’s natural gas! That was my impression while walking through the displays at the Alternative Clean Transportation Expo in early May at the Long Beach Convention Center. Suppliers were offering all sorts of equipment and services connected to this fuel that’s so much in the news.

Part of it was the location — California, whose Clean Air officials have endorsed natural gas by granting money to people who buy trucks and buses with engines that burn the stuff. They support other clean-burning fuels, too, but natural gas seems to be the anointed one.

The Wrightspeed Route turbine-electric hybrid truck that I review in the current Engine Smarts blog was running on compressed natural gas, something Ian Wright, the company’s president, noted during my drive. “It could run on other things,” he said, “but we chose natural gas for this truck.” So it fit right in with this expo. But is all the hype over natural gas accurate?

The oil companies tell us we have vast reserves of gas in the United States, and it would be foolish not to use it. However, does direct use as a motor fuel make sense? The gas itself is cheap, sure. But a heavy truck costs tens of thousands of dollars to equip for natural gas, and filling stations cost hundreds of thousands of dollars, even millions. Who can afford that? Not many, which is why natural gas will continue to be a very small part of the commercial truck scene, according to forecasts I’ve seen.

What if Prices Rise?

Yes, government-sponsored grants and tax rebates reduce the so-called incremental costs of buying a truck that runs on gas or another favored alternative fuel, and sometimes these incentives pay some or all of the cost of setting up filling stations. But incentives come and go as lawmakers bend with political and budgetary winds.

Some argue that incentives are absolutely necessary to spur early adoption. Others now are saying that the fuel’s price alone can make a good business case without any incentives. That’s been true since natural gas’s price has plunged due to massive drilling and production. At $2 or so per diesel-equivalent gallon, natural gas is a big bargain. But this can change, and might if producers cut back, as some are doing, and demand rises, as it will if more electric generating plants switch from coal to gas.

The president of Shell Oil has just predicted that natural gas’s price will double in a few years. There is some cushion between the prices of bulk gas and gas sold as motor fuel, but gas destined for trucks must go up if bulk prices do.

Won’t that do a number on any truck operator’s business case? Won’t people with a fleet of highly specialized trucks and tractors be left holding expensive gas bags that now cost more to run than if they had straight diesels? I’m not hoping this happens, just wondering what T. Boone Pickens and the other boosters of natural gas will say if it does.

Meanwhile, wouldn’t natural gas be better used as a feedstock for production of fuels that are easier and much less costly to handle and store on a vehicle? Why not let producers make the big investments in special refineries and let Pickens sell his gas to them?

Alternatives to Natural Gas

One such fuel is already here, and has been for many years: propane. Some is still a byproduct of petroleum refining (thus its more proper name, liquefied petroleum gas, or LPG). But more than half of it is made from natural gas and is widely used as a motor fuel (even if it gets little publicity).

Propane is stored under low pressure (75 psi), so tanks, while stout, needn’t be ultra-strong aluminum with carbon-fiber wrapping (for compressed NG) or cryogenic (for liquefied NG).

Propane’s price is now as cheap as natural gas’s, and it contains 85% to 90% of the energy in gasoline, which it normally replaces in conversions. Natural gas has only about 65% of the energy of diesel, which it’s replacing in a few highly publicized instances. Thus a truck needs a lot of expensive storage volume to get a reasonable range.

The other alternative fuel is dimethyl ether (DME), which can be made from natural gas or biomass (wood byproducts). DME is now being successfully tested in Europe, according to Volvo, which believes it is a viable fuel for the future. DME is propane-like in its handling requirements and diesel-like in its performance. It can be burned in diesel engines with few changes, and it’s clean enough that its exhaust might not need urea injection, as current diesels do, Volvo says.

The cost for DME should be considerably less than diesel fuel, says a small company that’s setting up a DME plant in Imperial County, Calif., east of San Diego. It will make DME from natural gas because it’s cheap and readily available, but could also use wood byproducts.

DME’s energy content is close to diesel fuel’s, and could sell for half to three-quarters of diesel’s price, according to some estimates. Thus it begs to be burned in diesel trucks. If it becomes widely available, anyone who believes in alternative fuels would be nuts to not seriously consider it.

But this is just me talking. We’ll see where the trucking world goes on this score.

Printer Friendly Version

Email This Story

Bookmark and Share

Alternative Fuels Hybrids: Related News

5/31/2012 – Does natural gas make sense as a truck fuel? Why not use it to make stuff that’s easier to handle?
Natural gas! Almost everything’s natural gas! That was my impression while walking through the displays at the Alternative Clean Transportation Expo in early May at the Long Beach Convention Center. Suppliers were offering all sorts of equipment and services connected to this fuel that’s so much in the news….

5/23/2012 – Turbine-Electric Hybrid Whirs and Whooshes But Saves Fuel, Maker Says
A chrome-plated exhaust stack emits a muted whoosh as this truck’s turbine engine spins at tens of thousands of RPMs, drawing the curious among attendees at this ride-and-drive event in downtown Long Beach, Calif. …

5/21/2012 – Bi-fuel impressions
The momentum toward natural gas as a motor fuel has been building for several years, and we don’t know how far it will take the national “fleet.” Some people would like gas to be a major automotive fuel because it’s comparatively clean and “green,” domestically produced….

5/16/2012 – Taking a Look at the Natural Gas Boom

When you’ve got everyone from oil tycoon T. Boone Pickens to the head of America’s largest truckload fleet to President Obama himself stumping for natural-gas-powered trucks, it’s easy to see why there’s so much interest in this less-expensive, home-grown alternative to $4-a-gallon diesel….

5/4/2012 – Hydrogen Fuel Cells Could be SoCal Fleet’s Future
Driver Tim Mabry eases his foot onto the pedal, and what appears to be a plain white Freightliner tractor moves ahead briskly, making only a faint whirring sound. We are being propelled through an industrial neighborhood in Rancho Dominguez, Calif., by an electric motor…

5/2/2012 – Parker Hannifin Helps Lowers City of Austin C02 Emissions by 55 Tons

The City of Austin has bought four hybrid refuse vehicles from the Hybrid Drives Division of Parker Hannifin Corp. in partnership with Autocar….

4/30/2012 – BAE Diesel-Electric System Available for Medium- and Heavy-Duty Trucks

BAE Systems is a multi-national company that says it has built HybriDrive electric powertrains for more than 3,500 transit buses in cities around the world, plus many thousands of straight diesel trucks for the U.S. Army. And it’s developing hydrogen fuel cells and electric propulsion systems. So it seems to have strong credentials to design and market HybriDrive versions for Class 6, 7 and 8 trucks….

4/27/2012 – Volvo Sees Promising Future for Bio-DME as a Vehicle Fuel
Volvo’s European Bio-DME project, which aims to assess whether there is a market for Bio-DME (Di-Methyl-Ether) for commercial vehicles, shows promise, the company says….

4/10/2012 – Propane’s Promise
Heavy-duty trucks running on the same stuff as your backyard grill?…

3/16/2012 – Florida 3PL Adding Natural-Gas Trucks to For-Hire Fleet

Saddle Creek Corp., a nationwide third-party logistics provider based in Lakeland, Fla., is taking delivery of the first 40 natural gas trucks in a planned purchase of 120….

1/30/2012 – Greenspeed to Chase Speed Record for Petroleum Fueled Trucks Using Vegetable Oil
This August, Boise State University‘s student club Greenspeed will use vegetable oil in hope of breaking the existing 215-mph world land speed record for all vehicles in the diesel truck classification, including those that burn traditional fuel….

1/19/2012 – Joule Secures $70 Million For Expansion of Biofuel Demonstration Plant
Startup company Joule Unlimited Technologies announced it received $70 million from undisclosed private and institutional investors, and the company hopes this funding will bring it closer to a breakthrough in biofuel technology….

1/16/2012 – FuelSmarts: Hybrids Paying Off for Bay Area Produce Fleet
San Francisco-based Veritable Vegetable is committed to being sustainable, from distributing certified organic fresh fruits and vegetables to using hybrids and fuel-saving strategies in its fleet of trucks.

As the nation’s oldest distributor of certified organic produce, Veritable Vegetable…

1/10/2012 – What Alternatives Are There to Diesel?
Once you start, the questions don’t stop. Every answer begets another query. Sooner or later even some of the experts will pause, scratch their heads, and might even say something like, “Beats me.”…

12/5/2011 – Frito-Lay Electric Delivery Trucks Hit the “Green” Streets of Orlando
PepsiCo’s Frito-Lay North America will roll out 10 new electric trucks in Orlando next year. In total, Frito-Lay will deploy 176 electric trucks this year in the U.S. and Canada, making Frito-Lay the largest commercial fleet of all-electric trucks in North America….

Emil Estafanous, CPA, CFF, CGMA